Saturday, September 6, 2008 - forestrynepal.org

Reframing Governance : Understanding Deliberative Politics in Nepal's Terai Forestry

Author:

Hemant R. Ojha

Publisher:

Adroit Publishers,, New Delhi, India

ISBN:

8187392835

Pages:

328

Synopsis:

The book develops a fresh approach to understanding governance using key concepts of Pierre Bourdieu (symbolic violence, doxa, field and habitus) and Jurgen Habermas (deliberative politics). Taking a case study of forest governance in Nepal Terai, the book analyses Habermas's ideal of deliberative governance from the perspective of Bourdieu's theory of practice. The case study shows that despite growing rhetoric of participatory and decentralized governance of forestry in Nepal, the actual practices of forest governance in Nepal Terai are controlled by dominant actors (mainly techno-bureaucratic and feudal political agents), with limited deliberative spaces actually available to, or proactively claimed by, the disadvantaged groups of people dependent on forests. The book demonstrates how rhetoric of participation and inclusion is actually a part of symbolic instrument of domination, and reproduction of pre-existing power relations. The analysis shifts the usual emphasis on 'conscious will' and 'rational behaviour' of individual human agents as the key elements for understanding governance, to an approach that interrogates the often overlooked symbolic structures of governance that systematically disadvantage some and privilege others. Thus, the book proposes that the analysis of governance and politics should be expanded to include the processes of domination and hegemony in the symbolic domain, including language and processes of deliberation, through which power relations are produced in a society.

Review:


"This book has a vision and clearly shows the possibility of a better way and explains what deliberative possibilities exist and their potential values on governance, and it does so within a framework which is at times, truly revelationary."
- Piers Blaikie,
Professor Emeritus, University of East Anglia

"This book makes a major contribution to deepening understanding of governance practices in Nepal. Though its case study focus is on forest governance (on which the author has wide experience), this book has implications for all governance debates in Nepal today and the transmission mechanisms linking global to local decision-making. The analysis is hard headed and avoids utopian "solutions" which mark so much developmental writing on Nepal, but it does offer hope of improvement through widening deliberative access."
- Dr. John Cameron,
Associate Professor, Institute of Social Studies, The Netherlands

"This is a fascinating study which deploys key concepts from the work of Pierre Bourdieu to make sense of the politics of forestry. It offers an important contribution to on-going debates about the value of Bourdieu's work in relation to the exploration of issues of governance and politics. It will be of interest to academics and activists alike."
- Prof Nick Crossley,
Head of Department of Sociology, University of Manchester

AttachmentSize
cover_page.pdf426.51 KB